Columnists

“Debt Shaming” Has Dampened Democracy

By India Walton

When I ran for mayor of Buffalo, New York, last year, my past-due parking tickets became a major reason for reduced favorability among voters. When Stacy Abrams ran for governor of Georgia in 2018, there was a lot of talk in the mainstream media about how much debt she was in. I share these examples because in general, the working poor do not willfully withhold payment for debts. We are faced with the very real decision between paying often illegitimate debts (like parking tickets and student loans) and feeding our children or paying for life-saving medical treatment for our loved ones.

New York State’s recently passed $220 billion budget has me thinking about the broad acceptance of the idea that the wealthy are best equipped to make the decisions that are supposed to benefit the public at large. The state decided that it was a wise decision to give $650 million to the billionaire owners of the Buffalo Bills while turning a blind eye to the crumbling infrastructure, lack of decent housing, and struggling education system in cities like Buffalo. We have now reached the stage of capitalism where corporate-dominated governments are more willing to invest public dollars into entertainment than in the public good.

Last month I attended a “debtors assembly” in Washington, D.C., hosted by The Debt Collective. It was the first time I publicly acknowledged how much student debt I carry – along with millions of other people. I am not alone and I have no reason to be ashamed. Not only was it liberating, but it got me thinking: what would municipal, state, and even federal budgets look like if we elect people who have had to decide between medication and student loan payments? Furthermore, what kind of talented and compassionate people would run for office if not forced into the shadows under the stigma and shame of medical, consumer or student debt?

As we look to 2022 midterm elections, voters are questioning the failure of a Democratic majority in Congress to deliver voting rights, the Build Back Better bill, and cancellation of student debt. The single and most simple thing President Biden can do to help save the Democratic majority this midterm, while stimulating the economy, is to cancel student debt; and he should do it without delay. In sharp contrast to other highly industrialized countries where higher education is inexpensive or free, approximately 45 million people in our country owe a total of $1.7 trillion in student debt.

We now have the crucial challenge of changing the narrative about who carries the burden of debt, who deserves personal agency, and who deserves decision-making capacity. That is why I am excited to continue to participate in vital coalition work as a member of the RootsAction team. (For more information on our#withoutstudentdebt campaign, visit withoutstudentdebt.us.)

The hardships imposed on working people have become even more harsh and inhumane in recent years, while vast wealth has been funneled into the pockets of a very few. As crucial steps to reduce income inequality, we need to reject “debt shaming” and insist on cancelation of student debt.


India Walton, who emerged last year as a powerful presence in the progressive movement after a stunning Democratic primary victory over a 16-year incumbent mayor of Buffalo, is now the senior strategic organizer for RootsAction.org. She is leading the RootsAction campaign #WithoutStudent Debt.

Reporters Desk

Recent Posts

Harbor Gateway’s Future Gets Another Green Light…Now Comes the Hard Part

After three decades, Los Angeles moves closer to implementing a community plan promising new investment,…

8 hours ago

Sweet Flower Dispensary Workers Vote Overwhelmingly to Authorize Unfair Labor Practice Strike

  LOS ANGELES — Sweet Flower Cannabis Dispensary employees represented by United Food and Commercial…

10 hours ago

Wilmington Flooding Forces Alameda Closure

  An overnight storm cell flooded Alameda street in Wilmington overnight, stranding several vehicles and…

10 hours ago

Governor Newsom Announces New Lifesaving Aid for Ukraine During Visit

  LVIV, UKRAINE — Nearly five years after Russia launched its full-scale invasion, Gov. Gavin…

11 hours ago

Governor Newsom Welcomes the Public to Samuel Oschin Air and Space Center

  LOS ANGELES — Gov. Gavin Newsom Nov. 16 announced that the Samuel Oschin Air…

12 hours ago

CD15 Joins Citywide Push to Protect Mixed-Status Families From Federal Housing Rule

Councilman Tim McOsker Nov. 13 joined Councilmembers Eunisses Hernandez, Ysabel Jurado, and Traci Park in…

12 hours ago