Briefs no image

Published on March 21st, 2013 | by RLn Staff

0

Rancho LPG Busted By EPA

Multiple Violations of Clean Air Act Cited
By Paul Rosenberg, Senior Editor

On March 14, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency sent a “Notification of Potential Enforcement Action” to Rancho LPG, for multiple, diverse violations of the Clean Air Act, including fundamental inadequacies with its risk management planning.

According to the EPA, Rancho “failed to develop and implement an emergency response program for the purpose of protecting public health and the environment, including at a minimum, procedures for informing the public and emergency response agencies in the event of a release.”

Responses from community activists ranged from elation to skepticism, while local Congress members expressed guarded optimism.

“EPA has made serious allegations,” Rep. Henry Waxman said.

Congresswoman Janice Hahn saluted, “EPA’s readiness to take strong action” while reiterating her position that “these tanks must be relocated.”

“I’m delighted,” said a former oil industry consultant Connie Rutter.

But Jeanne Lacombe, president of the Rancho Riviera Homeowners’ Association, was more skeptical, saying, “I don’t really know whether it’s going to have any teeth to it.”

Then, late Monday, March 18, after the initial version of this story was turned in, the EPA belatedly answered questions put to them over the weekend. The responses cast the story in a somewhat different light—that of a prolonged and troubling investigation, shielded from public scrutiny while the EPA worked with Rancho behind closed doors to correct almost all of the violations.

“Nevertheless, the companies are still responsible for any violations found during inspections that resulted in all six allegations,” EPA spokesperson Nahal Mogharabi explained.

Yet, the EPA stood by silently for years, while Rancho blatantly misrepresented itself as fully in compliance with all applicable rules and regulations.

Rancho’s failure to plan for protecting the public goes right to the heart of long-standing activist concerns that Rancho has never seriously prioritized public safety. Earlier indications of this lack of concern for the public include broken promises to hold safety drills that would involve the public, and broken promises to provide insurance information demonstrating that Rancho could cover the cost to nearby residents and businesses of a potential disaster.

EPA’s investigation of Rancho has taken almost three years. Onsite inspections on April 14, 2010 and January 11, 2011 were specifically cited in the letter, along with “subsequent information requests.”

“Based upon the information obtained during our investigation, EPA is prepared to initiate a civil administration action against the Companies to ensure compliance with federal law and assess a penalty,” the letter read. “EPA anticipates filing a Complaint in this matter on or about May 15, 2013, unless the Companies first advise EPA, with supporting information, of substantial reasons not to proceed as planned.”

“EPA has made serious allegations in this matter and if they are true, then San Pedro Terminal is failing to comply with the law,” Waxman said. “The terminal must be brought into compliance with the law immediately and held accountable for any lapses.”

EPA’s letter cited possible fines of $37,500 a day.

“I am encouraged to see the EPA signal its seriousness on an issue that is so important to the community I serve,” Hahn said. “The families who live and send their children to school near these tanks deserve to know that we will not tolerate anything less than total compliance with the federal law.

“While I continue to believe that these tanks must be relocated, the EPA’s readiness to take strong action to hold Rancho LPG to federal safety standards is an important step in the right direction.”

Two other problems identified with emergence response planning were:

(1) “the Facility’s emergency response plan …was not coordinated with the community emergency response plan” and

(2) “The Facility failed to clearly indicate to their own employees whether they would be emergency responders or would evacuate.”

Rutter had long been critical of Rancho’s risk management plan, arguing that it didn’t make sense in terms of the facility, and even suggesting that it had been cobbled together based on a plan developed for a dissimilar Texas facility.

EPA’s letter also cited five other problem areas where violations had occurred.

These include:

  • “The Companies failed to identify and assess its rail storage area as a process for inclusion in its Risk Management Plan…
  • “The Companies failed to adequately evaluate potential seismic stresses on the support structure for the emergency flare in accordance with design codes.”
  • “The Companies did not appropriately address the consequences of a loss of the city water system for fire suppression in the event of an earthquake.”
  • “The Companies failed to inspect Tank 1 according to a timetable set forth in API [American Petroleum Institute] Standard 653.”
  • “The Companies failed to ensure that the drain pipe located in the base of the containment basin and the valve located near Gaffey Street were included in the mechanical integrity program.”
  • “I’m overjoyed,” Rutter said. “I would dance…. This is the most positive thing we have had happen so far.”

But Lacombe was more focused on the limited nature of the violations EPA cited. The drain pipe violation paled in comparison to the larger issue that the impound basin can’t contain the butane, which readily turns into a gas, she noted. She also called the potential loss of city water in an earthquake “kind of pointless,” saying, “Any amount of water that they could pump over the fire would be pointless, because butane won’t burn out. It keeps burning, because it’s such a high temperature.”

Indeed, Rutter has repeatedly argued that the mandated safety procedures are all wrong for the properties of the gases involved. But she saw the EPA’s enforcement glass as half-full, rather than half-empty.

“I really have to credit [EPA enforcement officer] Mary Wesling, because the regulations and the laws are in such a mess,” Rutter said. “All the other politicians we’ve talked to, and regulators, they keep saying there’s nothing we can do, there’s nothing we can do, and she has found a way to do something, which I think is tremendous.”

The regulations may not have enough teeth in them, as Lacombe rightly worries. But EPA’s enforcement action has changed the policy and political environment, undermining Rancho’s long-standing efforts to portray its record as spotless and its critics as ill-informed know-nothings.

“They’ve actually said that we’re basically crazy,” Lacombe said of Rancho. “Really, they said, ‘You don’t know what you’re talking about. You’re just lying. You’re making up stories.’ They’re trying to portray us as a bunch of crazy environmental wackos…. But that never works. It’s easy to look up on wiki[pedia] the properties of butane. It’s easy to see that the public isn’t safe.”

And now the EPA has officially validated what community activists have been saying for years—or in some cases, decades. The facility clearly has not been perfectly safe and well-run as its operators have claimed.

Whatever happens next, that’s a bell that can’t be unrung.

Tags: , , ,


About the Author



Leave a Reply

Back to Top ↑
  • Like Us On Facebook!

  • Official RLn Twitter


  • The Guide to Fine Dining

    The Guide to Fine Dining
  • Calendar

    June 2015
    S M T W T F S
    31

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: ArtLong Beach Museum of Art Auction XVI

    Category: Community5th Annual Spring Garden Tour and Wine Tasting

    Category: EntertainmentClay Jenkins Ensemble

    1

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    2

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    3

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Kiwanis Club

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    4

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    Category: CommunityNight at the Aquarium

    Category: CommunityOpen Mic Nite

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    5

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    Category: CommunityHidden in Plain Sight: Day of Remembrance of Those Lost to Trafficking

    Category: EntertainmentDead Man’s Party

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: EntertainmentL.A.vation U2 Tribute Band

    Category: EntertainmentTaiko Center of LA

    6

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: Art7th Biennial Mid-City Studio Tour

    Category: CommunityFiesta Corazón del Puerto

    Category: ArtForgetting the Future - Entropy In the Reflective Age

    Category: EntertainmentHydrogen Jukebox

    Category: CommunityPacific Islander Festival

    7

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Shred: Festival of Skate 2015

    Category: Art7th Biennial Mid-City Studio Tour

    Category: CommunitySummer Concerts by the Sea

    Category: EntertainmentHydrogen Jukebox

    Category: CommunityPacific Islander Festival

    8

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    9

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    10

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Kiwanis Club

    Category: Community28th Annual ILWU/Propeller Club Seafood Fest

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    11

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: CommunityOpen Mic Nite

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    12

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterInside Llewyn Davis

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: ArtPortraying Popular Heroes

    Category: TheaterReel Rock Films: Inside Llewyn Davis (2013)

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: EntertainmentTim Weisberg Band

    13

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: ArtEntropy in the Reflective Age

    Category: CommunityJuneteenth Celebration

    Category: CommunityCatalina Island Summer Concert Series

    Category: TheaterRenoir

    Category: EntertainmentHollywood Stones

    Category: EntertainmentWally World

    Category: CommunityInformal Bird Walk on the Rancho San Pedro

    14

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityNon-Denominational Church Service

    Category: CommunityAnnual Los Angeles Food Festival

    Category: CommunitySummer Concerts by the Sea

    Category: EntertainmentBrad Dutz 4tet

    Category: EntertainmentSunday Jams Social

    15

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    16

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    17

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Kiwanis Club

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    18

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterLA Film Fest

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: CommunityOpen Mic Nite

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    19

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: EntertainmentTribute to the King of Pop

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: EntertainmentGabriel Johnson Heads Lineup

    Category: EntertainmentThe Gaslamp Killer Experience

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    20

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityCelebrate Father’s Day Terranea Resort

    Category: CommunityCatalina Above and Below

    Category: CommunityLA Brewers Beer Week Kickoff

    Category: CommunityConcert on the LA Waterfront

    Category: TheaterLes Miserables

    Category: TheaterDeath of a Salesman

    Category: EntertainmentGekko Project

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: EntertainmentWattsStax Revisited

    21

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityCelebrate Father’s Day Terranea Resort

    Category: CommunitySummer Concerts by the Sea

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    22

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    23

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    24

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Kiwanis Club

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: EntertainmentKristeen Young, Fea, and Guest

    25

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: CommunityOpen Mic Nite

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    26

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterRepo! The Genetic Opera

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: EntertainmentBones and Blues

    Category: EntertainmentRichard Sherman Trio

    Category: EntertainmentThe Family Crest and Run River North

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    27

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: Community2nd Annual Euro Bierfest

    Category: CommunityCoastal Sage Scrub 101

    Category: ArtVitality and Verve: Transforming the Urban Landscape

    Category: ArtThe Sharing Project

    Category: Artriverrun

    Category: EntertainmentComedian Hannibal Buress

    Category: EntertainmentDowntown Funk by the Sea

    Category: EntertainmentCaleb Quaye and the Faculty

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    28

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunitySeal Day 2015

    Category: CommunitySummer Concerts by the Sea

    Category: ArtIn the Garden, Art & Music Fair

    Category: CommunitySenior Comedy Afternoons

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: EntertainmentSummer Concert Series

    Category: EntertainmentA Salute to Santana

    Category: TheaterPick of the Vine-Season 13: Private Lives

    Category: TheaterPrivate Lives

    29

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAlexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    30

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    1

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunitySan Pedro Kiwanis Club

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    2

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: Community7th Annual Cars And Stripes Forever

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    Category: CommunityOpen Mic Nite

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterPick of the Vine-Season 13: Private Lives

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    3

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterPrivate Lives

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    4

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: TheaterTE San Pedro Rep’s Celebration Series

    Category: TheaterCock

    Category: Community4th of July Jazz and Blues Festival

    Category: Community4th of July Jazz and Blues Festival

    Category: Art4th of July Extravaganza

    Category: CommunityAll-American 4th of July

    Category: TheaterPrivate Lives

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

    Category: TheaterThe Heir Apparent

  • Take a Trip to Havana

    Take a Trip to Havana
  • Get Home Delivery!

    Get Home Delivery!
  • Join the RLn Network

    Subscribe Today:


    Options


  • Reset The Net: Protect Your Privacy

    Reset The Net: Protect Your Privacy