Community Voices Screen capture from YouTube video showing part of encounter between Porfirio Santos-Lopez and LBPD officers

Published on September 4th, 2013 | by Greggory Moore

1

Does Video Clearly Portray Excessive Use of Force by LBPD?

Every picture tells a story, don’t it?   –Rod Stewart

Sometimes being a cop is a bad gig, and not just when you’re in mortal peril. One of the most difficult choices a police officer may be forced to make is when to use force, and how much.

Taking cumulative stock of the two separate video clips that have come out thus far documenting Porfirio Santos-Lopez’s Labor Day run-in with Long Beach Police Department officers, along with the clip of his aggressing against two men prior to the 911 calls that brought officers to the scene, it’s clear that Santos-Lopez was not only uncooperative but combative, and so there is no doubt that the responding officers had justification to use force. The question, then, becomes how much force was appropriate.

The third video begins with the unarmed Santos-Lopez lying on his back while surrounded by four officers. That none of the officers has drawn a firearm would seem to indicate that none regarded Santos-Lopez as a potential mortal threat. Nonetheless, evidently Santos-Lopez is still resisting arrest, though his resistance at this juncture can best be described as noncompliance: he is not complying with officers’ commands that he roll over on his stomach (so they can handcuff him).

In fact, at this point he is not moving much at all, even as at least one of the officers tases him. It is only the baton strikes by a different officer that further agitates Santos-Lopez. That officer delivers a total six such strikes, three of which sickeningly resonate with the sound of wood against bone.

Santos-Lopez is tased a few more times before the officers—now having been joined by two others—move in closer and put their hands on him. Santos-Lopez continues to resist and is tased again, and eventually officers succeed in handcuffing him simply by forcing his arms behind his body.

“Many ask, ‘Why don’t you just jump on top of him?’” LBPD Sgt. Aaron Eaton told the Long Beach Post, anticipating one of the obvious questions posed by the video. “Well, here we have an individual who was asking to be killed, punching at officers and asphalt, and even attempting to kick an officer in the face at one point.”

Eaton expanded on this point to LBReport: “Officers used their batons and their tasers to get the subject to roll over onto his stomach so they could safely handcuff him.”

While these statements address the decision/need to use force, they sidestep the question of extent. How, for example, were repeated baton strikes to Santos-Lopez’s legs supposed to contribute to his rolling over?

As is standard practice regarding such incidents, the LBPD is conducting an investigation into whether the use of force was justified. Whether there is irony in the fact that within 48 hours of the incident Eaton is at least partly justifying the use of force in this case, even though the police often decline to comment on cases on the grounds that “the investigation is ongoing,” is for the reader to decide.

KCAL-TV reports that Santos-Lopez’s wife says her husband is an alcoholic who has been battling mental-health issues. Some are bound to use this information to foist more blame upon the police. However, Santos-Lopez’s mental capacity should be a non-issue in evaluating the officers’ actions. Police responding to a 911 call and encountering a combative suspect cannot be expected to divine his internal world, any more than they can be asked to defend themselves or the general public less vigorously because of what demons may therein reside. What they can—and are—asked to do is to stay the suspect’s aggression and apprehend him, using whatever force is necessary.

That last clause is incomplete. It should read: “using whatever force is necessary, but no more.” And while the videos don’t necessarily reveal everything that should be considered in this case, every picture tells a story, don’t it?

Tags: , , , ,


About the Author

Trapped within in the ironic predicament of wanting to know everything (more or less) while believing it may not be possible really to know anything at all, Greggory Moore is nonetheless dedicated to a life of study, be it of books, people, nature, or that slippery phenomenon we call the self. And from time to time he feels impelled to write a little something. He lives in a historic landmark downtown and holds down a variety of word-related jobs. HIs work has appeared in the Los Angeles Times, the OC Weekly, The District Weekly, the Long Beach Post, Daily Kos, and GreaterLongBeach.com. His novel THE USE OF REGRET was published in 2011. To be notified when a new Greggory Moore piece is published, send an e-mail to GreadersLB@yahoo.com.



One Response to Does Video Clearly Portray Excessive Use of Force by LBPD?

  1. Pingback: Random Lengths News | Independent And Free

Leave a Reply

Back to Top ↑
  • Like Us On Facebook!

  • The Guide to Fine Dining

    The Guide to Fine Dining
  • Calendar

    April 2015
    S M T W T F S
    29

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityComplete Whale Watch with Cabrillo Marine Aquarium

    Category: EntertainmentJanis Mann & Bill Cunliffe Duo

    Category: ArtSecond Sight: New Representations in Photography

    Category: TheaterMarilyn Forever - A Full-Length Opera

    30

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    31

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtLuminous, Transparent, Realistic Watercolor Workshop

    1

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    2

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    3

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtFirst Thursday Artwalk

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: EntertainmentSister Spit National Tour

    Category: CommunitySister Spit National Tour

    Category: EntertainmentRequiem at Rolling Hills

    Category: EntertainmentSomething Funny at the Warner Grand

    4

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: TheaterTaking Sides

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityBreakfast with the Easter Bunny

    Category: TheaterThe Crucifixion

    Category: EntertainmentBobby West at the Seabird Lounge

    Category: EntertainmentEwan Dobson and Guest

    Category: EntertainmentAmerican Monster Burlesque and Blues Show

    5

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    6

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    7

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtLuminous, Transparent, Realistic Watercolor Workshop

    8

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: TheaterDon’t be Afraid to Pogo

    9

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: TheaterFilm Festival: ‘The Red Pony’

    Category: EntertainmentMarian Marie at the Seabird Lounge

    10

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: TheaterFilm Festival Opening Night Screenings

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: EntertainmentHaden Triplets at the Annex

    Category: EntertainmentJulian Coryell Trio

    Category: EntertainmentRichard Turner Group at the Seabird Lounge

    11

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtMexican Mobile Consulate

    Category: ArtElks Lodge Groundbreaking

    Category: TheaterHollywood Nostalgia Tribute

    Category: EntertainmentLuca comes to the Annex

    Category: EntertainmentAzar Lawrence Featuring George Kahn

    Category: EntertainmentWhich One’s Pink

    12

    Category: ArtCan the Artists of the World be Censored?

    Category: ArtTies to Modernism

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: TheaterLAHIFF Presents DocSunday

    Category: EntertainmentSecond Sundays at Two

    Category: TheaterThe Suburban Showgirl

    Category: EntertainmentTradicíon at the Seabird Lounge

    Category: EntertainmentTribute to the Black Crowes

    13

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    14

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtLuminous, Transparent, Realistic Watercolor Workshop

    15

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityThe Quixote Festival

    Category: CommunityBirding with Wild Birds

    Category: CommunityEarl Ofari Hutchinson Gives Talk at CSUDH

    16

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityThe Quixote Festival

    17

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityLong Beach Grand Prix

    Category: CommunityLong Beach Grand Prix

    Category: ArtRolling Hills Homes Tour

    Category: CommunityThe Quixote Festival

    Category: CommunityRolling Hills Homes Tour

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: Theater‘Get On Up,’ the James Brown Story

    Category: EntertainmentJacob Szekely Trio

    Category: EntertainmentDavid Jackson at the Seabird Lounge

    Category: EntertainmentThe Sure Fire Soul Ensemble

    18

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtRolling Hills Homes Tour

    Category: CommunityLong Beach Grand Prix

    Category: CommunityRolling Hills Homes Tour

    Category: ArtCelebrity Lecture Series

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    Category: CommunityLA Local Beer and Food Fest

    Category: EntertainmentSuperhero Soundtracks

    Category: EntertainmentThom Rotella 4tet

    19

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityAuthors Day with Lisa See

    Category: TheaterIn My Life: Tribute to the Beatles

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    Category: TheaterThe Suburban Showgirl

    Category: EntertainmentNova Live at the Seabird Lounge

    Category: EntertainmentA Wailing of a Town

    Category: EntertainmentDavid Garfield Quintet

    Category: EntertainmentA Wailing of a Town

    20

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityWelcome to Night Vale

    21

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtLuminous, Transparent, Realistic Watercolor Workshop

    22

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    23

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: EntertainmentAndy Waddell

    24

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityTechnology Conference

    Category: ArtFarmer’s Market

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: EntertainmentBrian Auger’s Oblivion Express

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    Category: EntertainmentSouth Side Slim Blues

    25

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityEarth Day Celebration

    Category: CommunityNature Walk

    Category: CommunityGreen Prize Festival

    Category: CommunityRestoration Highlights Workshop

    Category: ArtHousing Development Opening

    Category: ArtRay Carofano: riverrun

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    Category: EntertainmentNoise Fest 19

    Category: EntertainmentSpock’s Beard

    Category: EntertainmentThe Gears, The Crowd

    Category: EntertainmentAzar Lawrence at the Seabird Lounge

    26

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: CommunityFarmer’s Market

    Category: ArtOpen Studios at Angels Gate

    Category: ArtQuilt Show

    Category: ArtLos Angeles Artists Propose Solutions to Human Trafficking Through Art

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    Category: EntertainmentLos Angeles Philharmonic

    Category: CommunityAbilities Night

    Category: EntertainmentOil Boom, Sir Madam, the South Hollows

    27

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    28

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtLuminous, Transparent, Realistic Watercolor Workshop

    29

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    30

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtPlacas: The Most Dangerous Tattoo

    Category: TheaterPlacas: The Most Dangerous Tattoo

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    1

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtPlacas: The Most Dangerous Tattoo

    Category: EntertainmentPiano Nights with Rob Klopfenstein

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

    2

    Category: ArtVarnette Honeywood

    Category: ArtMOLAA Presents Fantastic Mexico

    Category: ArtJohn Elgin Woolf: Master of Hollywood Regency

    Category: ArtPlacas: The Most Dangerous Tattoo

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterAbigail/1702

    Category: TheaterBye Bye Birdie

  • Take a Trip to Havana

    Take a Trip to Havana
  • Join the RLn Network

    Subscribe Today:


    Options


  • Get Home Delivery!

    Get Home Delivery!
  • Reset The Net: Protect Your Privacy

    Reset The Net: Protect Your Privacy